The Advisor – Autumn 2025: Amor Fati
Every bull market has its cheerleaders and its doomsayers. In September 2025 the chorus is split once again: some insist valuations are so extreme that caution demands selling everything; others argue that momentum and profits – especially from the Mega caps that dominate the indices – justify still higher prices. The paradox is not new. It haunted 1929 and 1999, resurfaced before the 2007-09 financial crisis, and reappeared in 2022. Investors, suspended between fear and greed, are left to choose between the risk of devastating loss and the risk of missing out.
The data are uncomfortable. The cyclically adjusted price-earnings (CAPE) ratio sits at a historical peak. Dozens of the largest companies trade at multiples that imply perfection. Market capitalisation towers over GDP. The equity risk premium has been squeezed to a sliver, indicating extreme valuations.




